Insult Politics in the Age of Social Media With Dr. Elliot Motte

Ryan Davis recently sat down with Dr. Elliot Motte to talk about his new paper, Insult Politics in the Age of Social Media.

Dr. Motte analyzed 3,000,164 tweets from 729 U.S. congressional members posted between June 21, 2017, and December 31, 2022. He found that toxic tweets received 16.8% more likes than non-toxic tweets from the same politician. But, Motte says, “When you’re posting toxicity sporadically or occasionally, that’s when you get an engagement premium. When you’re among the people who are more toxic at baseline, posting an additional toxic tweet is not going to generate more engagement.”

Motte cautions that this isn’t a way to win over political opponents: “You’re making your opponents even more entrenched in their beliefs, and you’re mobilizing your core supporters even more.” So this toxicity might give you a temporary engagement bump, but we agree with Motte: “That’s not beneficial to society as a whole.”

Listen to the full interview above or wherever you listen to podcasts.

Ryan Davis recently sat down with Dr. Elliot Motte to talk about his new paper, Insult Politics in the Age of Social Media.

Dr. Motte analyzed 3,000,164 tweets from 729 U.S. congressional members posted between June 21, 2017, and December 31, 2022. He found that toxic tweets received 16.8% more likes than non-toxic tweets from the same politician. But, Motte says, “When you’re posting toxicity sporadically or occasionally, that’s when you get an engagement premium. When you’re among the people who are more toxic at baseline, posting an additional toxic tweet is not going to generate more engagement.”

Motte cautions that this isn’t a way to win over political opponents: “You’re making your opponents even more entrenched in their beliefs, and you’re mobilizing your core supporters even more.” So this toxicity might give you a temporary engagement bump, but we agree with Motte: “That’s not beneficial to society as a whole.”

Listen to the full interview above or wherever you listen to podcasts.